The evidence stage of the court investigation has passed for more than an hour.

At this moment, even Utsunomiya felt a faint feeling of fear in his heart. How many more attacks can this kid in front of him launch? Kitahara's hands seemed to be holding a machine gun with unlimited bullets, pouring out a steady stream of weapons.

Fierce ammunition.

After all, how many bullets does he still have in his hand?!

Utsunomiya, who has many years of experience in court, this is the first time in his life that he feels that the investigation phase of a trial is so long and difficult. Every minute and every second feels like he is suffering some kind of mental torture. And

This Beiyuan still had a smile on his face, and his tone was neither hasty nor slow, nor hasty nor slow, as if he was deliberately trying to make the process longer.

Not only to torture the lawyer opposite, but also to use these pages of evidence as a shining slap in the face of the university.

Beihara held the remote control in his hand and said slowly, "Next, the plaintiff will present the fifth set of evidence and continue to present evidence."

Utsunomiya concentrated his energy like never before, listening intently and waiting for the attack that the other party would launch. In recent years, it can be said that it has been difficult to find opponents in intellectual property litigation. He never thought that he would actually be in

At the same time, this seems almost like blackmail, playing every lawsuit, and using all the strength to deal with the opponent.

Yes, a young man actually forced himself into this predicament.

To some extent, this can even be called a shame.

This is a shame suffered by an authority in Eastern jurisprudence.

Only Beihara's voice could be heard, revealing a hint of laziness, as he said, "Next is the third comparison report presented by the plaintiff. It is intended to prove -"

Beihara paused deliberately. Just during this pause, more than half of the listeners in the auditorium unconsciously leaned forward slightly. And the three judges on the referee's bench all focused on him.

on the body.

"The defendant's work edited by Fujimura was plagiarized in sections." Kitahara said with a smile.

Plagiarism into...Plagiarism?! Utsunomiya pricked up his ears, but he heard such an almost absurd purpose of proof. Does segmentation mean dividing into paragraphs? Wait! Why can even dividing into paragraphs be considered plagiarism? Could it be?

Even dividing an ancient book into natural paragraphs, just because the paragraphs happen to be the same, can it be considered plagiarism?!

Utsunomiya was about to refute immediately, but once he was bitten by a snake, he was afraid of straw ropes for ten years. The scene where he mistakenly regarded the collation of ancient books as a simple correction of typos came to mind again, and Utsunomiya had to force his words back.

In my mind, I can only wait and see how Beiyuan will make his move first.

I saw Beihara pressing the remote control in his hand with some ease, and said slowly: "Plagiarism in sections, which is the so-called similarity of divided paragraphs. In ancient writing, due to the high price of paper or bamboo slips, the ancients often made full use of the writing space

, without segmentation. This results in the original ancient books often having too dense fonts and making them difficult to read. Therefore, during the proofreading process, it is necessary to re-segment the text."

"Among them, if we compare the plaintiff's and defendant's edited works from the perspective of segmentation, we will find the fourth substantial similarity between the two edited works."

Kitahara walked to the whiteboard, raised his hand, and showed the content of the projection: "The second chapter of the first volume of the "Report to the Tang Dynasty", divided into 16 paragraphs in Shimochuan, and the 16th paragraph in Fujimura. The third chapter of the first volume of "Report to the Tang Dynasty",

Shimokawa is divided into 8 sections, and Fujimura is divided into 8 sections. In the fourth chapter of the first volume, Shimokawa is divided into 6 sections, and Fujimura is divided into 6 sections. In the fifth chapter, Shimokawa is divided into 7 sections, and Fujimura is divided into 8 sections. The first 6 sections are completely divided.

similar."

But I saw the projected whiteboard, constantly switching between the two chapters of the Tang Dynasty. The division of paragraphs is easier to identify than the previous comparison of different words and original texts. The latter requires the same specific words one after another.

To identify. And dividing paragraphs can be seen to be similar just from the "shape" of the article.

Beiyuan kept pressing the remote control in his hand, and in just 7 minutes, he finished all 83 chapters of "Send to the Tang Dynasty". He turned around gracefully and looked at the trial seat, "Chief Judge. Through the comparison just now,

It can be clearly seen that there are 83 chapters in total, including 76 ancient texts. Fujimura’s division of paragraphs is completely consistent with the proofreading of the plaintiff Shimokawa. Therefore, from this abnormal sign, it can be seen that the defendant Fujimura also

The plaintiff’s paragraph divisions were plagiarized!”

Utsunomiya was stunned when he heard these words.

This time "plagiarism in sections" is "plagiarism in sections" in the literal sense.

There are no traps or tricks.

However, this happened to be the case. Instead, it was a mockery of the extremely serious demeanor of the other party, Utsunomiya. Utsunomiya already felt that he had been completely humiliated.

This view, which is obviously untenable under copyright law, was raised openly in court.

But he himself had to seriously refute it.

This is really humiliating.

This is like a world champion in the 100-meter sprint who wants to join the national team, but the result is that the world champion in the 100-meter sprint is required to pass the most basic physical fitness test before he can join the team.

Ridiculous, simply extremely ridiculous.

"Chief referee." Utsunomiya stood up and looked at his student Takanashi, "The piecemeal plagiarism just proposed by the plaintiff's attorney is completely untenable conceptually."

"Dividing paragraphs is just a matter of putting the text on a new line, and it is just a simple rearrangement of the text. There is no creative element involved at all, and it is not protected by copyright law at all."

"This is like the similarity of the trademarks of two opponents. What you should prove is that the patterns of the two trademarks are similar, rather than proving that the packaging design composition around the trademarks is similar. The similarity of the packaging design does not belong to the similarity of the trademark patterns. Here

The same is true. Even if there are similarities in the so-called segments, they are only similarities that belong to 'packaging design' and are not within the scope of protection of copyright law at all!"

Utsunomiya has decided to completely tear this absurd argument to pieces.

Since the opponent uses this level of arguments to humiliate himself, there is no need for him to be polite anymore.

"And, Chief Judge!" the famous law professor further attacked, "Take our country's Oriental College Entrance Examination. In the Chinese character reading, there is also a test divided into Chinese paragraphs. The relevant test questions clearly contain standard answers.

From the questions set in the college entrance examination, it can be seen that there are only a few extremely limited ways to divide paragraphs. It is either divided into three paragraphs or two paragraphs. There cannot be a big difference at all."

"Considering this situation, segmental similarity cannot be used as an argument for so-called substantial similarity. The plaintiff has once again abused the so-called 'plagiarism' concept. This is not plagiarism at all. The plaintiff's attorney, from beginning to end, has
Chapter completed!