Font
Large
Medium
Small
Night
Prev Index    Favorite Next

Chapter 63 Bidding Collusion (3)

The city hall officials present were stunned. They did not expect that the male lawyer in front of them would actually trace the return path of the bid deposits paid by various companies. And, he actually found it. The four companies were different on the surface.

For a company, the deposits were all returned to the same account.

Such a fact can only show that these four companies are colluding together.

But it was revealed at the final stage.

The male lawyer in front of me has done this.

It's basically putting City Hall to death.

Hamano flipped through the documents and confirmed that these transfer vouchers were indeed the money returned from the deposit. The public lawyer's forehead couldn't help but begin to sweat. This lawyer named Kitahara can really see from a perspective that ordinary people can't detect.

Find a way to defeat your opponent.

He actually found evidence for even the extremely difficult-to-prove facts of the case such as collusive bidding.

As a long-time public lawyer, Hamano stood up again with his familiarity with regulatory rules. “According to the Municipal Engineering Bidding Act of the Ministry of Finance, only the bid deposits of different bidders can be regarded as transferred from the same account.

Collusive bidding. However, the facts of the case stated by the attorney now are that the deposit was returned to the same account. This is different from the situation stipulated in the law and cannot of course be regarded as collusive bidding!"

"And -" Hamano further added, "after the winning bidder is determined, the competitive relationship between the remaining suppliers no longer exists. What does it matter even if it is returned to the same account."

Kitahara sneered again, "Then, please tell me in your city hall, why the account used to receive the payment is the personal account of one of the presidents of the club. Why are four different companies sharing the personal account of one of the presidents? This

Is this something a financially sound club can do?!"

Kitahara's rhetorical question once again shocked the city hall side.

Hamano's brows furrowed, and he felt an unprecedented sense of crisis.

"I'm afraid you lack some business knowledge." Hamano also forced a smile and said, "The suppliers participating in the bidding are all peers in the same industry. There are economic exchanges or financing between them, isn't it?

Is it normal? In this case, they use one account to collect payments and settle their daily current claims and debts with each other. Is there anything strange about it?"

"Also." Hamano continued, "Perhaps due to the bidding venue, procedures and other issues at the time, in order to save trouble, they entrusted an account to collect the deposit. Isn't it normal?"

Kithara listened to Hamano's rebuttal and did not speak immediately.

He just stared at the public lawyer.

Her eyes were always on him.

Silence followed.

No response.

Just let time pass by minute by minute.

This silence actually made the city hall officials uncomfortable, and it also made Hamano uncomfortable.

This deliberate silence was as if the young male lawyer in front of him was deliberately waiting for the performance in the city hall.

Like a circus audience watching a clown's performance.

During this period of silence, Beiyuan did not say a word.

However, it made Hamano's argument seem ridiculous.

Hamano couldn't sit still for a while, "Lawyer Kitahara! I suggest you to research the business practices of the company. Don't bring some natural imagination into reality. Reality is complex and multi-faceted.

The relationship between enterprises involves both competition and cooperation. I advise you not to make false claims!"

"Since you said so." Beihara suddenly said, "Then please come up with the corresponding supporting materials. Prove that these four companies share accounts because they settle their daily economic transactions! Prove that these four companies share accounts.

Because of the troublesome bidding venue and procedures you just mentioned!"

"I want to remind you." Beiyuan's eyes suddenly became sharp, "Forging evidence is a crime."

These words were not simply spoken to Hamano.

It was told to all the city hall dignitaries present.

Although many city hall officials do not understand how serious the issue raised by the Kitahara lawyer just now is from a legal perspective, they are already worried. Even if they supplement the materials later, will the lawyer find out?

Flaw. Thinking of this, many dignitaries’ throats tightened.

A college lawyer who looks like he just graduated.

It actually made the city hall officials present fearful.

This is probably something that has never happened before.

Hamano is not afraid of Kitahara's intimidation. Who dares to say that the city hall forged evidence? The judges in the court will not cause trouble. At most, they think the evidence has no probative effect.

Hamano still replied: "We will add additional materials to explain later."

In the conference room, Kitahara had already pointed out the two projects that involved collusive bidding. However, they were all blocked by the city hall with supplementary materials.

Anyone with a discerning eye knows that the City Hall is absolutely capable of supplementing any required documentation.

This is also where Hamano’s confidence lies.

Administrative adjudication cases like this are mainly tried based on documentary evidence. Moreover, this is not an administrative lawsuit, and there is no corresponding time limit for the production of evidence. This means that the city hall can continuously supplement materials. If you want to use the project

In terms of the legality of the review, it is really difficult to defeat the city hall.

Witnessing all this, Miyagawa began to feel despair in his heart.

These four bank transfer vouchers were actually obtained by Kitahara through his previous relationship with Mizuho Bank Shimada. Shimada also took a very big risk and provided these transfer vouchers to help them. However, such precious evidence

, but it may be arbitrarily forged by the city hall and refuted by adding some documentary evidence. So, is there any fairness in this system?

Gradually, Miyagawa discovered more and more.

The numerous lawsuits he had experienced with Beihara before.

In fact, their opponent is not the Kawamoto Expressway, the Akagi Hotel Group, the District Prosecutor's Office, or Kyoto University. Their opponent is the system of this society.

Just like this moment.

Their opponent is not Shinjuku City Hall either.

It's a system that can operate unfairly like this.

A person who can forge documents at any time without being punished.

How to win in such an unfair case?

No need to think about it, you already know it.

The probability of losing is 99%.

This is a losing battle.

This is the cruel truth of the world.

When you choose to go against this system, you are destined to fail miserably.

Miyagawa's hands were shaking slightly. Her mood ranged from anger to unwillingness. She was unwilling to accept the cold, ruthless reality. But what could be done? After being angry and unwilling, in addition to giving birth to more despair, she could also

What are some?

Just then——
Chapter completed!
Prev Index    Favorite Next