In the courtroom, some senior professors at Kyoto University looked a little uneasy. Such an outrageous act of submitting multiple submissions for one manuscript was exposed, which undoubtedly disgraced the face of this top university. And what is even more embarrassing,

There were so many reporters sitting in this courtroom. You can imagine how exaggerated the tone the reporters, who always thought things were not lively enough, would use to exaggerate this matter.

Zhuze couldn't help but frown slightly. She suffered a dumb loss. However, in a lawsuit that was bound to lose, it was inevitable that the other party would have to perform harder to win the attention of the camera. Zhuze pressed

Don't worry about the anger in your heart. You don't need to pay attention to the opponent's tricks and moves. Just hit the opponent hard on the battlefield.

The female lawyer did not believe that the other party could make waves again.

It is impossible to cook without rice.

Weaving is impossible without cloth.

No matter how you perform, you must show real swords and guns.

However, just the next second.

Kitahara took a step forward and said, "The plaintiff's attorney will continue to express his cross-examination opinions on the third set of evidence presented by the defendant. The relevant internal rules of Kyoto University have shown that as a research result during the doctoral study, not only must it be a published result,

And it must be the research results during school.@ ”

Kitahara emphasized the words "while in school" heavily, and then a naughty smile appeared on his face like a child.

Zhuze didn't know why when he saw the male lawyer's smile, his heart suddenly tightened. During school? Why emphasize the words "while in school"? Could it be... Could it be?! Zhuze felt his heart beat suddenly, like

I suddenly found out what the lawyer on the other side was going to argue.

Kitahara took out a few pieces of A4 paper, which contained printed emails containing manuscript letters for Mikiko's two papers in question. The male lawyer clicked on the receipt date with his finger, and then turned around.

He looked towards the judgment seat and said:

"Chief referee, please pay attention to the date of publication letters involving two so-called plagiarized papers. Although my accuser, Mikiko, reported the results of the above two papers to the university, at that time, the two papers had not yet received the manuscript acceptance letter from the academic journal.

.After the plaintiff Mikiko received the acceptance of the manuscript, she had completed the university’s defense process and was on the university’s list for awarding doctoral degrees.”

"At the same time, Mikiko received the postdoctoral acceptance notice from the Tokyo Institute of Life Sciences and was already preparing for the postdoctoral work. Therefore, according to the time when the manuscript acceptance letter was issued, Mikiko has actually completed her doctoral studies and is not a doctoral candidate at Kyoto University

The two papers involved are not the research results of Mikiko while she is studying, but the research results of her graduation."

"According to the relevant regulations for awarding doctorate degrees within Kyoto University, she has no right to deprive her of the degree on the grounds that her post-graduation research results are fraudulent. The simple truth is that if a person obtains a doctorate with genuine talent, then she is a doctor.

.Even if she makes so-called misconduct in the future, she is still a doctor. The university can condemn and criticize, but it cannot deprive the other party of the degree on the grounds that there are problems with the academic achievements that do not belong to the doctorate. Mikiko allegedly involved two articles

The thesis is not considered a result of study, and the decision made by Kyoto University has no basis in law!"

Kitahara suddenly launched another offensive inadvertently.

No...it does not belong to the published results during the period of PhD study?!

If the lawyer just discussed it from the perspective of whether the manuscript would be published publicly, it was already surprising enough, but now launching an attack from the perspective of "while studying" is even more beyond the expectations of everyone present. This male lawyer

It seems that he has an amazing legal imagination and is always able to attack in unexpected places and in all directions.

Zhuze couldn't help but was stunned again. This male lawyer was really... really difficult to deal with. However, when he opened his mouth, he found that it was difficult to refute for a moment. The female lawyer gritted her teeth slightly and her thoughts were running rapidly. Unknown to her,

Unknowingly, she was having a hard time replying to the other party's lawyer.

"What the chief referee and the plaintiff's attorney said is not correct," Takezawa said, "The so-called publications during school years cannot be judged in isolation based on the time of receipt of the so-called manuscript acceptance notice. Plaintiff Mikiko's two concerns

The experiments, writing and other core work of this paper were all completed while studying at Kyoto University.

It should belong to the results of current reading. The plaintiff's attorney arbitrarily separated the time point of the paper, which is obviously contrary to common sense!"

"It goes against common sense?" Kitahara chuckled, "It seems that Lawyer Takezawa doesn't know much about the rules of survival in academia. There is a gold standard for whether the papers involving Eucalyptus are the results published by Mikiko during her time at school."

Beiyuan's voice suddenly paused.

This deliberate and abrupt end suddenly aroused more people's curiosity.

What is this standard?

These few seconds of intentional pause seem to have been stretched out for a long time. The plot is revealed just now, and the good show is always at the end. Only the revelation that happens after whetting people's appetite can achieve the most eye-catching effect.

Beihara said, "This standard is the institution to which the paper is published."

[Affiliation to which the paper was published]

[The so-called affiliation of a paper is the research institution to which the paper belongs. This is one of the most important indicators when calculating the output of a paper. It is an important indicator for universities to compete for public budgets from various institutions and compete for school rankings. 1

Even if a scholar publishes 10 papers a year, as long as the affiliation of these 10 papers is not his university, then these results are worthless to the university]

Kitahara took out a stack of materials and continued, "Chief referee, what the plaintiff's attorney is now showing is the communication emails between Mikiko and the two journals involved. Among them, the plaintiff Mikiko requested to be published in the journal and filled in her publishing unit as Tokyo

Institute of Life Sciences, so that the relevant papers can be counted as the scientific research achievements of his postdoctoral fellows. Among them, both journals have recognized it."

"This means that the affiliation of the two papers involved actually belongs to the Tokyo Institute of Life Sciences. They are the academic achievements of the institute, not the academic output of Kyoto University. The affiliation of the papers has always been statistical academic research.

An important indicator of output is the criterion for determining whether a scholar's publication can be attributed to a certain research institution. In terms of the affiliation of the paper, Kyoto University does not belong to the publishing institution of the two papers involved. @精/书馆
Chapter completed!