Chapter 55 Scissorhands
"The defendant first admitted that "The Journey to the East" was indeed first discovered by Shimokawa. Fujimura did not object to this." Utsunomiya stood in the court and smiled slightly, "However, the ancient book itself is a work in the public domain.
.I would like to ask the plaintiff, if Xiachuan could revise "The Journey to the Eastern Lands to the Tang Dynasty", couldn't Professor Fujimura do the revising?"
The law professor began to organize a new wave of attacks.
"Whether it is the first set of evidence or the second set of evidence presented by the plaintiff, there is a huge logical break in these evidence chains. That is their attempt to use the priority of discovering "The Journey to the East to the Tang Dynasty" to
Demonstrate the priority of school inspection work.”
"In fact, these are two completely different issues. Shimokawa was indeed the first to discover "The Journey to the East", but it cannot be concluded based on this that Shimokawa was the first to complete the editing work. My client Fujimura from
Xiachuan learned about the existence of "Report to the Tang Dynasty" and began to edit and revise it independently."
"The entire incident is actually completely opposite to what the plaintiff said." Utsunomiya walked in the court, and the sound of leather shoes step after step gave off a strong sense of oppression.
"After the defendant Fujimura independently carried out the work of sending Tang Ji to the school for a period of time, in order to avoid the waste of manpower and out of the friendly spirit of cooperation with scholars within the college, he then extended an olive branch to Shimokawa and invited him to participate in the sending.
Tang Ji’s schooling work, and the project was reported to the Academic Promotion Committee as a scientific research project.”
"But the problem is that although the defendant intended to support the plaintiff, the plaintiff failed the defendant's good intentions." Utsunomiya took out a piece of A4 paper from the table. He saw that the document was the scientific research of "The Eastern Land Parade to the Tang Dynasty"
Attendance list for project coordination meetings.
"Everyone, the material I have in hand is the list of participants in various meetings of the Sentangji scientific research project." Utsunomiya said, "We can see very clearly that the plaintiff Shimokawa was absent from all meetings without exception.
Attended a meeting!”
"Furthermore, he has never completed the schooling tasks assigned to him on time. The progress of Qiantangji's schooling that Shimochuan is responsible for is far behind the progress of other personnel in the schooling project!"
Utsunomiya slowly raised his head and looked at his student, "Chief referee! In this situation, a person who never attends project meetings and is lazy to complete assigned tasks, can we make him have the points in "The Journey to the East"
Are you qualified to be signed on the school book?”
"The answer is of course no!"
"In fact, the plaintiff is extremely greedy for merit. He could not complete the thesis quota set by the university, so he put his crooked ideas into editing works. The plaintiff wanted to complete the editing work of Qing Tang Ji alone, but he was not able to do so.
The speed of schooling lags far behind the project team chaired by Fujimura.”
"Therefore, in this case, the fact that Fujimura came into contact with Shimokawa Amatera's works does not exist!" Utsunomiya's voice was resolute, as if arousing turbulent waves in the court.
In the words of this famous law professor, things took on a completely different look. Instead, Shimokawa turned into a villain who coveted the achievements of the Fujimura project team. This rhetoric exuded an extraordinary power of seduction.
, some students in the auditorium even doubted whether they should trust Professor Shimokawa.
Miyagawa was stunned as she listened to Utsunomiya's lecture. She never expected that the university teacher in front of her could keep his face straight and speak such shameless words.
It echoed the haggard expressions of Hirose and Shimokawa as they were repeatedly tortured by the academy.
The sense of justice in the heart of this woman in her twenties was ignited again. For a moment, she could not restrain her inner impulse and stood up directly.
"You're talking nonsense!!" Miyagawa ignored his manners and cursed out, "Chief referee! The description just given by the defendant's attorney has no factual basis and is completely slander and attack on the plaintiff's character! The defendant never notified the plaintiff to participate.
These meetings!”
"Why did other teachers and students participate, but Shimokawa did not!" Utsunomiya retorted bluntly.
"Moreover, don't I have any factual basis?" Utsunomiya waved the two A4 papers in his hand, "I have proved that the proofreading manuscript discussed at the so-called project establishment seminar is just a test of the first two pages of the Tang Dynasty.
It’s just proofreading. It’s impossible for Fujimura to come into contact with all the proofreading manuscripts claimed by the plaintiff during the project establishment seminar!”
The tough tone and gesture were like an iron rod hitting Miyagawa's head directly.
Miyagawa opened his mouth slightly, but could not utter a word of rebuttal.
At this moment, Utsunomiya took a step forward again. This famous professor knew Miyagawa. A few years ago, when he went to the University of Tokyo to give academic lectures, a teacher from Tokyo University came with undergraduate students who took the copyright law elective.
Lecture. After the lecture, he also communicated with these undergraduate students. He remembered that a teacher from Tokyo University once introduced this student named Miyagawa, saying that she was the first in the copyright law course.
Although the matter was small, he had a clear impression.
Is Dongda’s undergraduate program in Copyright Law No. 1?
Utsunomiya sneered a little. He could read a lot from the expression of the girl in front of him. She must have just become a lawyer. Although she tried her best to show the appearance of a mature lawyer in her words, she showed a bit of clumsiness.
.
And there was a feeling of unconfidence hidden in a pair of eyes.
Utsunomiya, who has taught many students, knew that the female lawyer in front of him was the kind of good-natured student who would become frightened and nervous with just a few scoldings.
Especially obedient female students with excellent grades, they have self-esteem as top students, but the inferiority complex in their bones makes their self-esteem shatter at the slightest touch.
In this case, on this occasion, I will completely crush your self-esteem as a Tokyo University student!
This chapter is not finished yet, please click on the next page to continue reading the exciting content! Utsunomiya's gaze became colder, hitting Miyagawa's figure like a nail. He took a step forward again, feeling the huge pressure on his body.
suddenly released.
I could only hear him say, "The plaintiff wants to prove through evidence that Fujimura had contact with Shimokawa's works. In other words, he is trying to prove the first element of the principle of 'substantial contact'. However, the works he contacted must be completed works.
If it is contact with an unfinished work, it does not meet the requirements of the principle of 'contact materiality'."
"In fact, the contact facts proved by the plaintiff are extremely vague. It may be that Fujimura came into contact with Shimokawa's edited works. It may also be the other way around, that Shimokawa came into contact with Fujimura's edited works. Moreover, considering that Shimokawa only fought alone
. And Fujimura led his monks and doctoral students to participate in the revision work of "Report to the Tang Dynasty". The process of Fujimura's revision project should be much faster than that of Shimokawa. It is impossible for Fujimura to plagiarize Shimokawa's revision of "Report to the Tang Dynasty."
"Furthermore -" Utsunomiya suddenly raised his voice, "In this case, Fujimura's rough version of "The Journey to the Eastern Lands" has been published.
School copy. Who can say for sure that the Dian Xiaoxuan in Shimokawa’s hands at this moment is not a plagiarism from Fujimura’s already published Dian Xiaoxuan!”
Utsunomiya's voice echoed in the courtroom.
This argument was like the roaring wheels of a train that completely crushed Miyagawa's evidence, demonstrating the profound knowledge base of the authority of Oriental Intellectual Property Law.
Chapter completed!