Font
Large
Medium
Small
Night
Prev Index    Favorite Next

Chapter 356 The most difficult case (six)

Nangong Tengfei: "Please note that Zhang Qian took a plane to a certain country after get off work on Friday. If there was no accident, he could return to Dongtang before going to work on Monday. Zhang Qianren is already a dead person. Now the shameless police and unscrupulous lawyers try their best to let the dead take the blame. Let me ask, shouldn't the dead be suspected of being guilty? Let me ask, what evidence does the police have to prove that Zhang Qian stole the vase?"

Nangong Tengfei: "On the contrary, it is more intuitive to buy theft case in Bai Ru's studio. Some people have witnessed that the insider testimony shows that he knows that the thief's target is a vase and also knows the time of the thief's action. There is physical evidence, the insider collects a deposit of 300,000 yuan for the thief. Yes, the thief in the video denied that he had stole, but the agreement between the thief and the insider was to give 700,000 yuan after the matter was completed. Since the vase was fake, the thief did not need to give 700,000 yuan to the insider. This is why the thief lies."

Nangong Tengfei said: "To sum up, because the death of the person related to the vase, that is, Zhang Qian, has given everyone an opportunity to take advantage of. Here I want to say that even the deceased enjoys the rights granted by law."

After saying this, Nangong Tengfei was a little breathing. His words were very organized and shocked the audience for a moment, and the court was quiet.

The one who broke the silence was Sunny: "You were prepared for a long time, why didn't you stand up against Cao Yun's video evidence?"

Nangong Tengfei smiled: "Isn't this you?"

I'm a scoundrel! The two of them agreed and let Cao Yun get out, and they decided to win and lose each other, and ended the case. It's understandable that he is shameless, because he is shameless. It's wrong for Nangong Tengfei to have no credibility. I'm a double standard? I'll double standard, you bite me.

Nangong Tengfei's words burned the war on Cao Yun, which was very cruel. Nangong Tengfei showed that there were objective burglaries. The judiciary cannot choose to believe just because of the thief's words, and the judiciary believes in evidence more.

This stab made Cao Yun very painful. The damn old fox thought he would let him out. Unexpectedly, he had already thought about the blame.

Even Bai Ru thought it was very reasonable when Nangong Tengfei said this. Regardless of Zhang Qian, there was indeed a theft in the studio. Someone invaded the safe, and the target was the vase of the safe. This is a fact.

There was no other way, Cao Yun looked at the information with his mobile phone: "We first understand the details of this Simodog. Simodog can tell the details of communication with the insider. It can basically be confirmed that Simodog is the person who invaded the studio safe. Simodog is between 34 and 37 this year, and is from Southeast Asian countries. His method of committing crimes can be traced. He never snatched the site, nor did he hack into cameras and computers through hackers. He chose to bribe the insider."

Cao Yun said: "It can be confirmed that Simotuo committed the crime. There were four cases in four years. He bribed four insiders. The offer ranged from 100,000 to 3 million yuan. The reason why these four cases were confirmed was that the police solved the case and caught the insider. According to the insider's description, Simotuo contacted them in a close to the tone. They received all the stolen money from the Malay account, and their transactions were paid 30% of the deposit first, and then 70% after the matter was completed."

Cao Yun said: "In these four cases, Simotuo has never cheated any insider, and he has not given a penny of the money he should have given. The final payment has not been short. If it were to say that the vase was not the biggest case Simotuo had ever done, he stole the crown of Thailand and was worth a lot of money. The cost of hiring an insider was three million. Pay 900,000 first, and then 2.1 million, not a penny less."

Cao Yun said: "Next, let's learn about fake vases. Fake vases are imitation handicrafts produced by Dongtang. You can buy them on Ceramic Street. Please note that Simotuo does not know Chinese. Simotuo came to Dongtang for the first time. How did he know where to buy fakes with basically the same appearance? He is unfamiliar with the place and the risk of leaving traces on fakes is very high."

Cao Yun: "When returning to the studio safe, Simotuo can take the vase directly without leaving a fake vase. He doesn't care about the time of the crime, and he doesn't have to cover it up. He is a thief, he is a wanted criminal. We can't just take tinted glasses to see his IQ with his IQ. On the contrary, his IQ is quite good."

Cao Yun: "A person with such a credibility doesn't trust him just because he is a thief. Is that right? In addition, from the testimony of the insider, we can know that Simotuo consulted him about the situation in Dongtang City, such as calling the police, speed of police dispatch, traffic conditions, etc. He never talked about where to buy fakes."

Cao Yun: "Don't talk about Simotuo, we are familiar with Dongtang. Now we are going to buy exactly the same fakes. Do you know where to buy them? Outsiders don't know where Ceramic Street is. Do you know the second defendant lawyer? Who knows Ceramic Street, please raise your hand... No one knows. I have learned that Ceramic Street is not a street, but the name of a store. I have an assistant named Hanzi. She is very serious in doing things and found this place."

Cao Yun handed his cell phone to the judge: "This is a photo my assistant got from Ceramic Street. The pixels are not very high, but it can be seen that before the vase auction, Zhang Qian's wife entered the Ceramic Street shop. When she left, she held a bag in her hand. It was vaguely seen inside the bag as a carton, which was roughly the same size as the vase."

Cao Yun: "Yes, this is also a circumstance. It cannot prove that Zhang Qian dropped the bag, or even prove that Zhang Qian's wife bought a fake vase. As lawyers, we must first talk about conscience. Who do you think is lying? In fact, it doesn't matter. The theft case really exists. The police make a conclusion. The judge judge judges a case and the insurance company pays money. We will settle the case. However, there is another thing in this world called the truth. Maybe we can't see the truth, maybe the truth is unwilling to face us. But we cannot create a truth against our conscience because we don't know the truth. Thank you everyone."

Compared to the disputes in the first trial, this trial was a real trick. Nangong Tengfei and Cao Yun kept drawing out their trump cards, which were all unknown to the other party.

Nangong's sonorous confrontation with Cao Yun's awesomeness, elevating the quality of the trial to a new level.

There was also a silence. Nangong Tengfei said: "Lawyer Cao said it very well, but one thing is wrong. The law tells evidence, and the truth is sometimes not something that the law can protect. Otherwise, there would be no inference innocence. If the case is judged and investigated based on subjective preferences, how many people will be wronged?"

Continue to remain silent. At this time, the judge needs to make a stage summary. If there is no problem, go directly to the final stage: the plaintiff and defendant's closing statement. Then, ten minutes to half an hour later, the judge announces the final ruling result.

In the second trial, Sonny became a statist, and Nangong Tengfei and Cao Yun fought with real guns. Nangong Tengfei was responsible for evidence, and the actual theft case in the studio was in existence, and there was no evidence that Zhang Qian stole a vase. Cao Yun interpreted his testimony from various aspects such as character and reputation, and the evidence was all circumstantial evidence.

There is a relatively embarrassing thing about the laws of the East Tang. Dong Tang was originally a mainland law system, but over the past decade, it has gradually changed into a marine law system. The evidence is a link that the mainland law system focuses on. Cao Yun proposed character, reputation and logic, etc. are related to the legal system focus on.

The judge put his hand on the table and tapped the table with his left thumb. He was also very confused. If he was determined to lose the shrimp and shrimp auction, he ignored Cao Yun's various subjective evidence, and there was no need to debate. This is also the weakness of the mainland legal system, only looking at evidence. If he was sentenced to lose the white shrimp auction, he was ignoring the evidence. The judge subjectively supported Cao Yun and objectively supported Nangong Tengfei. Both sides were equally in power and had sufficient reasons. It was impossible to distinguish who had the upper hand and it was difficult for him to make a judgment.

So the judge looked at Sunny, who was grazing cattle and eating melons, and said, "What do the third defendant think?"

Sonny was stunned for a moment, brother, the content of their debate had nothing to do with me.

The judge added: "From the police perspective, although you are a new policeman, I think you are still very capable. I have been a judge for twenty years and apologized to the lawyer for the first time. Although I am very angry, it does not affect my view of your ability."

Wow! So it’s so cool to be praised!

Cao Yun felt that the judge was the messenger. It was almost done. You just gave the conclusion and everyone who lost would admit it. The judge was unwilling to end like this. Nangong Tengfei could understand the judge. If the judge said such words, it means that based on the current trial situation, the judge could not draw a conclusion.

Sonny stood up: "As a policeman, I subjectively support the first defendant, Lawyer Cao. However, as a policeman, I also have to tell the evidence. I helplessly support the second defendant, Lawyer Nangong."

I'll go! Let me have an opinion.

During the deadlock, Cao Yun stood up and added: "The third defendant, what is the follow-up investigation by the police on Zhang Qian's death?"

Sunny said: "The case was transferred to the national punishment, and the national punishment was communicated with the other party. If you get the two bodies back through spraining ankle channels, there is basically nothing else."

Cao Yun asked: "In other words, the police have never been to the scene of the car accident?"

Sonny: "No need, we trust our peers in a certain country."

Cao Yun looked at his mobile phone: "According to the statistical report, there are serious judicial cases in a certain country. Are you sure that it is not Zhang Qian and his wife who have escaped? The body has not been handed over yet, and you have not asked to collect DNA. Is this considered a dereliction of duty?"

Sonny was about to answer, and Nangong Tengfei finished the fight: "Three million US dollars were transferred to Zhang Qian's wife's account. The other party was a Malay account. Have you communicated with the Malay police?"

Sonny felt very bad, why did he start an operation on himself? Sonny said: "National Examination should be able to communicate with Malay."

Nangong Tengfei asked: "The three classes don't care about this matter? Everyone looks at the plaintiff, don't explain stars, charity ambassadors, etc. Even if an ordinary citizen's private property is infringed, the police have the obligation to help him. There are obvious clues that have not been investigated. Is this considered a dereliction of duty?"

Sonny smiled bitterly: "Two, it's useless forcing me. I'll come back after a survey, and you still have to do it. You either Cao Yun died or he was Nangong Guard. To be honest, we have been very dedicated to Bai Ru, surpassing ordinary citizens. The Malay account is obviously a leather bag and money-slaughtering account. The bodies of Zhang Qian and his wife will be transported back sooner or later, and they can't be concealed. Besides, they have all arrived in a certain country, so there is no need to pretend to die."

Sonny: "I have an offer, I understand that the judge is not easy to make a decision now. If the two defendants have no objection, then the plaintiff will decide who will compensate."

Cao Yun and Nangong Tengfei were stunned for a few seconds. This proposal sounded good. But can you respect everyone's profession a little? In a civil lawsuit case, if you ask the plaintiff to decide who to compensate, then you will still sue?

Bai Ru said: "I respect the final ruling of the court."

The judge finally summarized the stage: "From the current trial results, the shrimp and shrimp insurance lawyer's statement is reasonable and convincing. However, the evidence is not conducive to shrimp and shrimp insurance. It can be confirmed that there was indeed a case of burglars stealing in Bairu Studio, and it is impossible to confirm that Zhang Qian's burglars stealing of vases. As a court, we cannot adopt the testimony of the thief who has not been arrested. If there is no problem with all parties, then please prepare and make a statement about the closing of the case."

Oh no! Cao Yun was so sorry, the judge had already expressed his attitude.

Sonny raised his hand and everyone watched Sonny together, shut up! Stop making trouble.

Sonny completely ignored everyone's eyes and said, "I would like to make a suggestion. Miss Bai Ru, you are not short of five million. You are also very clear about the case trial. I personally suggest that you donate five million, and each of the white shrimp and shrimps will be 2.5 million. It is beneficial to everyone. The case can be announced to the public. Since the suspect is a habitual criminal in Southeast Asia who has not been arrested, or a major suspect appraiser who has passed away has a major suspect, if it is impossible to determine who stole the real vase. Charity ambassador Bai Ru proposed that both parties each pay 2.5 million to donate the money to the charity organization. Shrimp and Bai Shrimp agreed to this proposal, but insisted on donating the donation in Bai Ru's name and voluntarily increase the donation amount and donate three million, because Miss Bai Ru was a vase purchased by six million."

The judge said: "The third defendant's proposal belongs to a settlement..."

Cao Yun slapped the table with his left hand and stood up: "Sorry, I'm sorry, I'm going to be ruling. The insurance company must have a conclusion from the police or the final ruling of the court before the insurance company will give the money. The shrimp and shrimp insurance company is a company that abides by rules and regulations and self-discipline, and will not violate the rules of the game in order to make the mud."

Cao Yun: "After the trial, I can only play the last card. Please forgive me for the White Shrimp Auction... After Miss Bai Ru bought the vase, she contacted the shrimp and shrimp insurance company to take out insurance. The shrimp and shrimp insurance company contacted the white shrimp auction according to the industry regulations, and asked the white shrimp auction to send an appraiser to the scene to appraise the vase. There are many appraisers who can be dispatched for the white shrimp auction, but why did Zhang Qian, the appraiser in charge of the vase?"

Nangong Tengfei replied: "White Shrimp Auction believes that Zhang Qian is most familiar with this pair of vases, and it is the most authoritative to determine whether it is genuine."

Cao Yun said: "My understanding is the opposite. Just because Zhang Qian is the appraiser and staff in charge of the vase, he cannot be invited to appraise. The insurance company contacted the white shrimp with the attitude of trusting the white shrimp auction. The white shrimp did not explain in the process that Zhang Qian was the person in charge of the vase. In this case, the insurance company could lose, and the loss was due to the reason why the white shrimp auction was cheated."
Chapter completed!
Prev Index    Favorite Next